SEARCH:
Sign in | Join | Help
search Mercola.com
 
FREE Subscription 
The World’s Most Popular Natural Health Newsletter
More Reasons You Should NOT Rely on Bottled Water

If you've switched to bottled water as your primary source of water in hopes of avoiding the perils of drinking unfiltered tap water, you may want to consider your options.

Scientists have concluded the longer a bottle of water sits on a shelf -- in a grocery store or your refrigerator -- you'll consume a greater dose of antimony, a silvery white metal of medium hardness that breaks easily.

The amount of antimony that leeches into the water you're drinking depends on the bottler and can vary greatly. Among 63 brands of bottled water produced in Europe and Canada, researchers detected concentrations of more than 100 times the typical level of antimony in clean groundwater (2 parts per trillion).

What's more, after letting bottled water samples sit for six months on a shelf at normal room temperatures, the concentration of antimony exploded by 90 percent among European brands and 19 percent in Canadian brands. The common denominator: Most products were packaged in polyethylene terephthalate (PET) containers. In fact, the lead researcher believes the amount of leeching will differ, based on exposure to sunlight, higher temperatures and varying pH levels.

Using a reverse osmosis filter, however, enables you to rely on your own well or municipal source for safe, clean water and give up bottles for good.

Environmental Science & Technology Online January 24, 2007






 
 Do you find this article interesting?
Comment on This Article Community Comments (37)
 
 
Posted On Feb 01, 2007
Another difficulty linked with bottled water is the fact that it has gradually educated us into a certain belief... namely that it is okay for someone to 'own' water and then sell it to us.  Which in turn has made us an easily convinced public when governments turn around and hand ownership of water to private corporations.  No fanfare when they do this because they don't want to draw our attention to what's going on.  No protests from us when we learn about this because we're all accustomed to the notion that someone, somewhere owns water and can therefore charge us for it.   And of course with the fluoride in it and our air we're just that bit more docile anyhow!

Isn't it a bit of coincidence that private companies are pushing to own water all over the world (even the water that falls as rain in your backyard mightn't be "yours") just as oil runs out??  Isn't it a bit of a coincidence that Governments are handing over water rights to private companies who will charge us for water and pay taxes on each sale to our Governments??  Isn't it a bit of coincidence that that kind of thing would help redress tax revenue income lost when we all start driving cars on water that cost us nothing??  But no... no, they'd never... no, the authorities are on our side... they're our friends... they're not friends with the oil companies... they'd never prioritise the interests of their tax coffers and the profit margins of oil companies over citizen's rights to drive around using a freely available eco-friendly fuel... no, they wouldn't... nah, never... that's not their style... is it?!


 
Sean Uisce
Apprentice User Apprentice User, Joined On 11/2006
Sean Uisce  
Replied

dibbs
Novice User Novice User Joined On 2/2007
dibbs  
 
Posted On Feb 05, 2007
I am concerned about the bottled water for infants that you can mix with powdered formula if a mother cannot breastfeed.  Our grandson passed away at 9 weeks of meningitis only to have my son accused of SBS.  It took the coroner 6 weeks and 2 neuro people from CA and Ethan's brain tissue to be sent to Washington D.C. to a neuro pathologist to come to the conclusion that is was meningitis.  Apparently, someone called my daughter-in-law  regarding the formula(powdered)  There's so much more to all this but I was wondering about the infant water they sell. Thank you


yarrow
Apprentice User Apprentice User Joined On 2/2007
yarrow  
 
Posted On Feb 13, 2007

I have an R.O. unit with added filters. The holding tank is lined with plastic as I believe they all are so it's probably not any better than plastic bottles??? I have also heard that when water is made this pure it becomes acidic and the lack of minerals leaches the minerals out of your body. You can buy a TDS meter (total disolved solids) for about twenty five bucks. Before filtering, my tap water reads about three hundred, after the R.O. the meter reads three. I have tried adding minerals back like concentrace but don't know much about it.
The company I got my R.O. unit from is out of Canada and can be found on E-bay, they have reasonable prices

There is a very interesting point made about water in the movie, "What The Bleep"


slapshot44
Novice User Novice User Joined On 2/2007
slapshot44  
 
Posted On Feb 13, 2007
To yarrow:
Water can dissociate from H2O to H+(acid) and OH-(base).  But if water is pure, or made pure the total amount of H+ and OH- are equal to each other which gives pure water a pH of 7.  If you test your tap water with some pH strips after if runs through the filter it should be 7.
Secondly, it would be the base, OH-, that would leach minerals out.  This is because minerals have a positive charge to them and would not attract the heavily protonated (H+) acid.
I think instead of adding back minerals to your water, that you could obtain those minerals from foods, especially vegetables.  Just a thought.


dshacks
Novice User Novice User Joined On 2/2007
dshacks  
 
Posted On Mar 03, 2007
There are two significant concerns with reverse osmosis treated water.  The first is associated with the operation of the unit itself.  As with any filtration (RO strictly speaking is not a filter, but does perform a filtering function never the less) device maintenance is a critical necessity to maintain both effectiveness and safety.  Over time particulates will become trapped within the internal structures.  Over 99% of all bacteria, viruses and human pathogens of all types can be found attached or living on surfaces.  Relatively few can be found floating around in the air.

Because of this without scrupulous attention to cleaning and maintenance the RO units become breeding grounds for all sorts of microbes that can lend themselves to the production of very unhealthy water.

The second concern is that RO water when produced has a depressed pH due to the removal dissolved minerals.  The lack of minerals, the depressed pH and the natural solvency of water combine to produce a water that has a quite corrosive nature.  In industry this requires all piping and storage materials to be either plastic or stainless steel.  In humans this water will have a tendency to remove minerals form the body and can create a condition of mineral defficiency if used exclusively as a water source without adequate mineral supplementation.


Witch Doctor
Apprentice User Apprentice User Joined On 9/2006
Witch Doctor  
 
Posted On Mar 04, 2007
Sean - I don't understand your concept of ownership.  If you or I filter and bottle the water from my tap, or even water from underground, no one has the right to take it from me - we own it.  If I have a well, I have paid for the well and the equipment to get it into a bottle - again I own it. 

Companies can do the same thing.  They put a price tag on it, but they are not forcing anyone to buy it.  It has no value unless people choose to buy it, because they like what the company has done with the product.

This is the way it should be.

Just my opinion.
Duane