SEARCH:
Sign in | Join | Help
search Mercola.com
 
FREE Subscription 
The World’s Most Popular Natural Health Newsletter
Debating the Health Benefits of Coffee

A "controversy session" about the health benefits and dangers of drinking coffee was recently held in Washington, DC.

The scientists attending the meeting discussed the evidence that coffee can help ward off type 2 diabetes, and that it can help prevent certain cancers while increasing the risk of developing others.

Coffee may protect against colon, rectal, and liver cancers through several mechanisms, including reducing the amount of cholesterol, bile acid and natural sterol secretion in the colon.

But coffee can also raise the risks for leukemia and stomach cancer.

Coffee could also help reduce type 2 diabetes risks, possibly through the action of its component chlorogenic acid, which slows the absorption of glucose in the intestines.

Yahoo News May 1, 2007


Dr. Mercola's Comment:

Please, don't interpret this as an excuse to hit your local coffee shop for a super-sized caffeine kick. Coffee studies tend to conflict quite a bit. Despite what you may have heard in the news recently about the health benefits of drinking coffee, the evidence isn't nearly as convincing as the experts have assumed.

My guess is that it was promoted by researchers and reporters that merely wanted to justify their coffee habit. Please remember, caffeine is a drug; it just happens to be a very common legal drug, but it's a drug nevertheless -- with very powerful actions.

I don't know about you but I don't want to rely on drugs to achieve any benefits if I can find a natural alternative. The only justification for using coffee would be to help you overcome severe jet lag to help you stay awake until your desired bedtime. Even then, it should be used with sublingual melatonin immediately prior to going to sleep.

It is true that there have been studies attesting to coffee's contribution in cutting your risk of developing breast cancer, liver cancer and diabetes. But coffee drinkers are also likely increasing their risks of other deadly diseases, such as stomach cancer and leukemia, which has prompted some experts to suggest that pregnant women and children limit their intake.

From my point of view it is reprehensibly irresponsible to suggest that it is OK for pregnant women to drink coffee. There is a substantial amount of research showing that it clearly increases their risk of spontaneous abortion. Even the conservative New England Journal of Medicine and the FDA advise pregnant women to avoid coffee.

Drinking coffee also has other well-documented problems. For instance, it may interfere with your body's ability to keep homocysteine and cholesterol levels in check, most likely by inhibiting the action of the vitamins folate, B12 and/or B6, for one. Additionally, coffee has been previously associated with an increased risk of stroke and rheumatoid arthritis.

It's very interesting that science is becoming more aware of both the risks and advantages of consuming coffee at the very same time that many are leaving Starbucks behind for soft drinks, which are among the most toxic things anyone could consume and are a major contributor to the epidemic of obesity that currently plagues our planet.

Related Articles:





 
 Do you find this article interesting?
Comment on This Article Community Comments (80)
 
 
Posted On May 04, 2007
My thoughts, in which I always have one:
1. Most conventional coffee uses pesticides, herbicides, etc
2. Most are highly processed
3. Most are coated in sugar
4. Most use unfare trade
5. Excess coffee creates dehydration which leads to a tons of other dysfunctions
6. Excessicve coffee intake actually spike cortisol levels, but in the end you end up with the inability to release cortisol and end up in adrenal fatigue

Coffee has been used for thousands of years as a medicinal in a lot of medicines. I think drinking organic fair trade coffee in the morning is OK. This is what I recommend:
1. Drink 1-2 glasses of water first thing upon waking
2. Take cod liver oil and glutamine (assists with blood sugar control) upon waking
3. Eat a breakfast high in good fats
4. Drink your one cup of organic coffee with raw cream

The best is to drink coffee no later than 12 noon, since coffee has a half life of 6 hrs. As well, I use espresso to get people off coffee if they are drinking excessive amounts. Typically, one shot of espresso has about 22mg of caffiene in it, in relation to the 120-220mg of caffiene in a cup of coffee (depends on the size and bean). Of course, during the day drinking half your body weight in onces of water per day.

 
Josh Rubin
Moderator User Moderator User, Joined On 6/2006
Josh Rubin  
Replied

phooey
Savvy User Savvy User Joined On 2/2007
phooey  
 
Posted On May 04, 2007
I completely agree Josh.
I tell my clients to drink organic coffee, if they drink coffee, since it is one of the most heavily sprayed plants, with filtered water, and non bleached filters, and no garbage sweetners or fake whiteners. I put a little raw milk in mine. Ray Peat wrote one of my favorite articles on the topic. Ray worked closely with Dr. John Lee on the benefits of progesterone. Look up: raypeat.com/articles/articles/caffeine.shtml
It is well referenced. It seems that many of the studies that show coffee as a negative are using either massive quantities of coffee or straight caffeine. According to his article the studies that show pregnant women should not consume coffee, the rats were given large doses of caffeine, not coffee. I am not saying that pregnant women should drink coffee, just repeating what the article says. Read studies VERY carefully and thoroughly.
And as he states when you isolate an individual compound out of nature and take it in high doses you will get  a drug like effect. This is the same as taking individual amino acids, vitamins or fatty acids at high doses. It is no where near the same as getting these compounds the way nature put them in food. They are balanced. Coffee has magnesium and according to Peat benefits the thyroid, and increases progesterone in the blood and tissue. With most women having thyroid problems and excessive estrogen, this MIGHT be beneficial in the right amount.
Remember also that Dr. Mercola posted the study a while back about fast and slow metabolizers of caffeine. There are some that would be better off not drinking much at all. But properly prepared in small amounts coffee may have some benefit for some. Listen to your body.


JL
Savvy User Savvy User Joined On 6/2006
JL  
 
Posted On May 04, 2007
There are studies that say women with high levels of cortisol are about 3 times as likely to have a miscarriage in the first weeks of pregnancy.  Of course there are many things beside coffee that can contribute to this, including stress, but  some may wish to stay on the safe side.






Reesacat
Savvy User Savvy User Joined On 1/2007
Reesacat  
 
Posted On May 04, 2007
I worked with an OB-GYN in the 1980's who if one of his patients was
high-risk or had had a miscarriage recommended avoiding caffiene
(coffee, tea, soda, etc.) just to be on the safe side.  It was easy to
do and did help a few of our patients to get pregnant.


Wigiat3
Users with negative points NoviceUser Joined On 4/2007
Wigiat3  
 
Posted On May 05, 2007
Josh:

How serious should we take you and your comments?  You can't even spell caffeine.


Josh Rubin
Moderator User Moderator User Joined On 6/2006
Josh Rubin  
 
Posted On May 06, 2007
Wigiat3,
What I post are my thoughts, beliefs and recommendations that I use and have used since I started working with clients 7 years ago. This is a blog and I just type what comes to mind. I am busy, but enjoy adding to this community of like minded people. You can take what you want from my posts or you can take nothing. But let me ask you this, are you going to listen to your MD and all their research just because they use spell check and spell 100% all the time?

As I have said before, judgements are hidden expressions of unmet needs!


Sarah Onisick
Savvy User Savvy User Joined On 6/2006
Sarah Onisick  
 
Posted On May 19, 2007
What if I have just one cup of coffee, that is organic.  Will that take away the risk of pesticides, etc.   After that I drink tea, including green tea, but I love that first cup of coffee. 
I am concerned, though, because Dr. Mercola's article said that coffee promotes leukemia, and I have CLL, stage 0, which I know is common in folks as they get older.  I am 64, and found out during yearly routine bloodwork that my white cell count is higher.  I have had two CAT scans and have no signs of it, that way or swollen lymphs.
Does one cup of organic coffee hurt?
And I know what you are going to say... I just don't want to hear it...  :)


N. C.
Novice User Novice User Joined On 11/2006
N. C.  
 
Posted On May 19, 2007
I agree, I drink organic coffee only. I drink it black  with ginger capsules to sooth stomach and help wake up. I do drink 1-3 cups a day right up until 3- 5pm. It never interferes with my sleep. I only drink it slowly , one 8oz. cup over 1-2 hour period to avoid high and low effect.


Sarah Onisick
Savvy User Savvy User Joined On 6/2006
Sarah Onisick  
 
Posted On May 19, 2007
So is it the pesticides, etc. in coffee that promote leukemia?   And will one cup of organic coffee in the morning, after water and cod liver oil, which I already take first thing, before coffee ... be okay?
I have CLL Stage 0.
I drink tea after that, and often have green tea, or add Dr. Mercola's green tea drops to my water.
I can't get raw cream, but can get low temperature, unpasteurized milk from happycowcreamery.  I can't find any information on low temperature pasteurized milk.  Can you help?


katieannpc
Savvy User Savvy User Joined On 2/2007
katieannpc  
 
Posted On May 22, 2007
After seeing a documentary on coffee - I believe it was PBS - I will stick with my Organic, Shade Grown, Fair Trade coffee from Cafe Campesino. They are about 40 minutes north of me, and their coffee is available on the web at www.cafecampesino.com and at several stores in the Atlanta area - if you are in SW Georgia, it's also available at Tommy Mc's Produce in Albany. Best coffee I ever had!

Since my 2nd pregnancy, my coffee intake is way down, I used to drink it all day long. But during that pregnancy - I couldn't even stand the smell of coffee.  I am back to a cup or two of my lovely morning drink now. 

Anywhoo - just passing on a great source of AWESOME COFFEE for those of you who are interested! Check 'em out on the web - they have flat shipping so if you can, buy whole bean in large quantities for the best deal.



pinkskittles
Savvy User Savvy User Joined On 10/2006
pinkskittles  
 
Posted On May 22, 2007
I didn't know that espresso had less caffeine than a cup of coffee, I thought it was the other way around, that's great to know. I got this organic latte one time at this cafe made with everything organic (milk, espresso, flavour shot)--it was really good! It restored my views on lattes.

I enjoy coffee every now and then for the taste. I get organic fair-trade coffee. I can drink that stuff black as long as it's made right in a coffee press. People who drink anything else are really missing out on good coffee! Coffee should be enjoyable to drink black, if not, then it can't be good coffee (since you have to cover it up with cream and sugar).

 
 
 
Posted On May 04, 2007
I was hoping to get a Metabolic Typing perspective on this from either Josh Rubin or Dr. Mercola. If you look at Biobalance II by Rudolph Riley, coffee tolerance is highly dependent on metabolic type.

Coffe study

The above study showed that slow caffeine metabolizers had an increased risk of myocardial infarction (heart attack).

If Metabolic Typing has validity, one would be well-advised to avoid making indiscriminate judgements as to whether coffee is "good" or "bad". It might well be helpful for one type and harmful for another.

 
moises
Apprentice User Apprentice User, Joined On 6/2006
moises  
Replied

Josh Rubin
Moderator User Moderator User Joined On 6/2006
Josh Rubin  
 
Posted On May 04, 2007
Moises,
I personally take each person as an individual when they come in. Yes I use MT, but there is much more to it than that. I follow my recs above for most, but my recs might change to none, etc depending on what type of serious illness or dysfunction is sitting in front of me.

I had a recent client with H.Pylori, Candida, certain AA deficiencies, Stage 3 Adrenal fatigue and a lot of serious digestive issues and pains, I rec substitues instead of coffee and even espresso. They would just make things worse.


Witch Doctor
Apprentice User Apprentice User Joined On 9/2006
Witch Doctor  
 
Posted On May 04, 2007
moises - one could hope but metabolic typing does not work for political issues like coffee.

 
 
 
Posted On May 04, 2007
This post was deleted because it violated our Terms Of Use :
Comment does not pertain to the topic of the article or does not provide value or insight to the discussion. Submit stories or comments linking to affiliate programs, multi-level marketing schemes, or off-topic content or any other system that will result in your personal financial or commercial gain.

 
Katy B
Savvy User Savvy User, Joined On 3/2007
Katy B  
Replied

Bridestein
Savvy User Savvy User Joined On 12/2006
Bridestein  
 
Posted On May 07, 2007
Beware of mochas! I was surprised and dismayed to discover that a large number of places use Hershey's chocolate syrup. How about a nice dose of HFCS to go with that coffee? There goes my last vice. :-(
I believe Starbucks uses powder but who knows what it in that? I would not patronize them anyway. (but you should see the looks on the tourists faces when you tell them the nearest one is 70 miles away; priceless!)
So, like Duane, I'll stick with cocoa powder and cream.

 
 
 
Posted On May 21, 2007
As a chinese doctor, I have to say, ONCE AGAIN, western medicine screws it up.  You can put regular gas in any car and it runs.  Well guess what?   We're NOT cars!!!!  Some people can drink some coffee and some, say, those with stomach heat, cannot.  One clue is if coffee gives you awful breath, you have too much heat and shouldn't drink coffee, which is considered energetically hot in Chinese medicine.  This is why you get such divergent results from a "scientific" Western study, and why western medicine kills so many people.  Commercial medicine depends on the one-size-fits-all solution, which is a solution for a handful of people and a death sentence for most others.

 
acu doc
Apprentice User Apprentice User, Joined On 5/2007
acu doc  
Replied

Reesacat
Savvy User Savvy User Joined On 1/2007
Reesacat  
 
Posted On May 21, 2007
Well said, Doctor!  Thank you for the information.

 
 
 
Posted On May 19, 2007
Moderation moderation moderation.
I believe if you drink ORGANIC & in MODERATION you will get the best of it and you'll avoid the pesticides and the chemical flavors etc.
around 1905 science only knew 4 vitamins, now we have long a list, so there are a lot we still didn't discover yet.
so enjoy your organic coffee in moderation and enjoy both worlds.

 
imagine_203
Novice User Novice User, Joined On 5/2007
imagine_203  
 
 
 
 
© Copyright 2009 Dr. Joseph Mercola. All Rights Reserved. If you want to use this article on your site please click here. This content may be copied in full, with copyright, contact, creation and information intact, without specific permission, when used only in a not-for-profit format. If any other use is desired, permission in writing from Dr. Mercola is required.
* These statements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. This product is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any disease. If you are pregnant, nursing, taking medication, or have a medical condition, consult your physician before using this product.