SEARCH:
Sign in | Join | Help
search Mercola.com
 
FREE Subscription 
The World’s Most Popular Natural Health Newsletter
Egg Producers Deceive Consumers With Bogus Omega-3 Claims

Eggs

Eggs that advertise their omega-3 content may be defrauding the public by claiming that they can reduce the risk of heart disease.

The FDA specifically prohibits such claims on foods such as eggs that are high in cholesterol.

While the FDA does permit claims for a possible reduced risk of heart disease related to the omega-3's DHA and EPA, less than half of the advertised omega-3 content in many eggs comes from EPA and DHA.

The Center for Science in the Public Interest (CSPI) identified seven egg companies making deceptive claims, including Land O Lakes, Eggland's Best, Safeway Specialty 3 Eggs, Gold Circle Farms, The Country Hen, Full Spectrum Farms, and Giving Nature.

CSPI June 21, 2007


Dr. Mercola's Comment:

If you have been convinced of the importance of increasing your omega-3 intake based on the very compelling research, you may not be getting what you think you are when you purchase eggs boasting omega-3's for heart health.

At least that is what CSPI wants you to believe.

Unfortunately. although CSPI has done some good things in the past, they, like most conventional physicians, are seriously confused about the saturated fat and cholesterol issue.

If you have been reading this newsletter for awhile you will know that this concern is not justified and we all need some healthy saturated fat and cholesterol.  Eggs happen to be a phenomenal source.

Eggs really are one of nature's most
perfect foods -- when they're organic. Organic eggs come from chickens that have been fed only organic feed, without pesticides or GMO's in the grains. Just be careful, as eating eggs every day increases your chances for developing an allergy.

The real issue with omega-3 in eggs is that they typically are not high in DHA.  You have to read the label VERY carefully. Most commonly the chickens are fed plant based omega-3 fats, like flax so they are high in ALA.

Nothing wrong with this, but the animal based omega-3 fats, DHA and EPA, are far more useful to you. Some farmers do actually feed their chickens fish sources of omega-3 and do have higher EPA and DHA levels.  However, if they only use DHA from algae sources, this will not be as good because it is unbalanced.

So nothing is wrong at all with the omega-3 eggs, just make sure that you examine precisely what omega-3 fat is in the egg and how it got there.

DHA and EPA are pivotal in preventing heart disease, cancer, and many other diseases. The human brain is also highly dependent on DHA -- low DHA levels have been linked to depression, schizophrenia, memory loss, and a higher risk of developing Alzheimer's.

ALA is not equivalent in its biological effects to EPA and DHA, which are more rapidly incorporated into plasma and membrane lipids. In fact, ALA must be converted into EPA and DHA in your body, but this conversion has only a 10 to 15 percent efficiency rate.

Related Articles:





 
 Do you find this article interesting?
Comment on This Article Community Comments (40)
 
 
Posted On Jun 24, 2007
I have several questions. Who, exactly, are the folks at CSPI? The article referenced does not have an author and the article's site has no information onsite about the organization. There is an address and a non-toll free number. That doesn't encourage me to find out about the organization. What are their credentials? Where is the backing for their claims? They are going after the egg producers but their premise is that the FDA says only two kinds of omega 3 fats are good for you. Show me the studies. The FDA says all kinds of things that are bogus. Let me see the proof.

 
Magnolia
Savvy User Savvy User, Joined On 6/2006
Magnolia  
Replied

Reesacat
Savvy User Savvy User Joined On 1/2007
Reesacat  
 
Posted On Jun 24, 2007
Well said, Magnolia!


APhotoWizard
Novice User Novice User Joined On 6/2006
APhotoWizard  
 
Posted On Jul 14, 2007
Aren' t these the same folks that went on a rampage a few years ago about the movie theaters killing us with red palm oil in our popcorn?  I they are now againt red palm oil claiming it is not only causes heart disease, but it is destroying the rain forrest.  While they seem to be doing some good. I look very carefully into anyting they say, becasue  they seem to fly off the handle without thinking. - Jerry


APhotoWizard
Novice User Novice User Joined On 6/2006
APhotoWizard  
 
Posted On Jul 14, 2007
Aren' t these the same folks that went on a rampage a few years ago about the movie theaters killing us with red palm oil in our popcorn? They are still against red palm oil claiming it is not only causes heart disease, but it is destroying the rain forest.  While they seem to be doing some good. I look very carefuly into anything they say, becasue  they seem to fly off the handle without thinking. - Jerry


Amanda Rose
Savvy User Savvy User Joined On 6/2006
Amanda Rose  
 
Posted On Jul 14, 2007
The article is right and it is wrong. It is definitely right about the importance of EPA and DHA in health. ALA (from plants) can convert to EPA but the conversion is not guaranteed in each of us. Seafood is still the best source of these fatty acids, but I think we need to look at our diets and see what we can improve. Eggs are one opportunity.

The thing about the Omega 3 eggs is that they are higher in DHA. Hens are able to convert the ALA to DHA. Humans generally cannot. In a study of breastfeeding moms, adding two of these eggs a day to their diets improved the ratio of Omega-6 to Omega-3 fatty acids in their breast milk.

So it is correct that there are better sources of Omega-3 fatty acids. It is not correct that these eggs make no difference in our diets and health.

->>Omega 3 Eggs and Breast Milk
->>DHA content of Omega 3 Eggs



helpingheart
Savvy User Savvy User Joined On 6/2006
helpingheart  
 
Posted On Jul 14, 2007
Magnolia - you are right on!  Very well said!

Who are these people at CSPI?!  Why should we BLINDLY listen to every "news piece" that comes along?

QUESTION ALL "NEWS"!

I get my organic free-range local fresh eggs from a farmer in my area who is at all the weekly farmers markets.  They are the best real fresh eggs I've ever had!


Dr. David Spitz
Apprentice User Apprentice User Joined On 12/2006
Dr. David Spitz  
 
Posted On Jul 14, 2007
Katy B. -- You say you can't digest red meats,,,i wonder...have you tried Grass Fed Beef?

Dr Dave

 
 
 
Posted On Jun 22, 2007
Only purchase fresh organic free range local eggs, most of the major brands in the egg game are a highly processed cooperatives, or are regional oligopolies where the eggs do not even get to market for several days to weeks after being laid.

"Cooo cooo ca chu...I'm The Egg Man..."

Uncle Russ

 
Russ Bianchi
Savvy User Savvy User, Joined On 9/2006
Russ Bianchi  
Replied

Bridestein
Savvy User Savvy User Joined On 12/2006
Bridestein  
 
Posted On Jun 22, 2007
Right on, Russ! I recently had the opportunity for the first time to buy local, fresh organic eggs. Now those are eggs! I couldn't believe the difference between them and the free-range organic eggs sold at the grocery store. It's almost worth risking the bear just to raise a couple of chickens. Glad I don't have to.
(funny how its always 'the bear' instead of 'a bear', like there's only one)


Lynn46
Savvy User Savvy User Joined On 12/2006
Lynn46  
 
Posted On Jun 30, 2007
Russ,
Congratulation on your knowledge of the Beatles' song lyrics! I echo your advice, but, everyone, please keep reading...

All,
Find a local farmer who sells eggs in your area, and pay them a visit. Ask how they raise their chickens, and how they feed them. Look for answers like: (1) the chickens have free access to pasture so that they can eat plants and insects (in the spring, summer, and fall); (2) the pasture is pesticide and herbicide free; and (3) the chicken feed is either soy-free or if the feed contains soy, the soy is GMO-free. If you hear the right answers, then you have found the best local place to buy your farm-fresh eggs. Don't worry about "organic certification" from your local farmer. If you like his/her operation, then you are getting the best eggs possible and you are supporting your local farmer in making a living for him/herself and their family.

My local farmer has wonderful eggs ($3/dozen, a great price). These eggs taste much better than organic eggs from supermarkets, have deep orange yolks (from the plants and insects), and thick sturdy shells. These characteristics indicate that the chickens are healthy, and the eggs have naturally high omega-3 fatty acids. Eggs are now one of my favorite foods--right up there with my raw milk!


Wilde
Novice User Novice User Joined On 11/2006
Wilde  
 
Posted On Jul 14, 2007
I would be asking your local egg producer if the chicken feed contains rapeseed (canola). Like most consumers, much of the farming industry has bought into the marketing myth that rapeseed is healthful. Many of you here already know that it's a product that should be avoided like the plague. The fact that scientists are developing a 'new generation' GM canola is evidence that the first-generation GM plants have inherent problems.

http://www.nexusmagazine.com/articles/canola.html


PutzFamilyFarm
Novice User Novice User Joined On 7/2007
PutzFamilyFarm  
 
Posted On Jul 14, 2007
Great Post Lynn46, I agree, pay your local family farm a visit and see how they raise their chickens and ask how old their eggs are.  We have been raising chickens for several years and of January have stopped purchasing SOY based feed.  One more thing to add, don't fall for the marketing ploy of Free-Range Vegetarian eggs!  Free- Range doesn't necessarily mean they have access to fresh grass or sunshine -- and chickens aren't vegetarians.  Pasture raised omnivores is the way to go, just ask a chicken!


cin_203
Savvy User Savvy User Joined On 10/2006
cin_203  
 
Posted On Jul 14, 2007

and now a word from the best free range chicken farmer in the state of Oregon,
(boy are we a lucky bunch that have access to their eggs!)


..."This is all so very true.  The "old" way to raise pastured hens was
not  only to have them free ranged on grass, but to feed them beef scraps
as  their protein source.  Note that in the old days, that would've
been pastured  beef -- a triple boost of good fats and omega 3's. 
Chickens used to be fed clabbered skim milk as well - again a great source of
animal proteins


 
 
 
Posted On Jun 22, 2007
Is the Center for Science in the Public Interest a good organization to evaluate the eggs?

 
Reesacat
Savvy User Savvy User, Joined On 1/2007
Reesacat  
Replied

Cacao
Savvy User Savvy User Joined On 3/2007
Cacao  
 
Posted On Jun 22, 2007
I do not know, but I sure do like eggs!

My brother-in-laws father had a chicken farm until the city government appropriated his property using eminent domain. This made way for several businesses who were coveting his property. The city would then make more in taxes than they could from a simple chicken farmer.

My brother-in-laws family and our family has eaten eggs our entire life time and we are happy and healthy. Moderation in all good things is the key.


Bryan - oz4caster
Apprentice User Apprentice User Joined On 6/2006
Bryan - oz4caster  
 
Posted On Jun 22, 2007
Reesacat, I think CSPI's criticism of cholesterol and saturated fat in eggs is way off track and unwarranted.  Eggs are an excellent food that people have been eating for thousands, if not millions of years.  Russ is right, buy eggs from pastured chickens locally - they're the best in nutrition.


phooey
Savvy User Savvy User Joined On 2/2007
phooey  
 
Posted On Jun 23, 2007
CSPI's exec director Michael Jacobson is one of the biggest saturated fat and cholesterol phobes there is. We get their nutrition action newsletter every month at the hospital I counsel at and in every issue they preface saturated fat and cholesterol with "artery clogging". This is the same organization that promoted, quite heavily, trans fats in the early eighties. There is a great article written by Mary Enig at www.westonaprice.org about how this organization bounces back and forth on what is and is not healthy. They are almost like the Physicians Committee for "IR"Responsible Medicine, but not quite as bad. I have written him several times to back up this artery clogging claim and of course I get no response. I even asked once if the PhD at the end of his name I see in the newsletter stands for  "Place Head in Derriere". This could be why I get no response.
Eggs DO NOT have a lot of saturated fat. What are most of these chickens fed? Grains and other assorted items, and probably lots of things we don't want to know about. Grains are high in polyunsaturated fats. This would mean that the chicken and the egg would be high in polyunsaturated fat since, "you are what you eat". Same for the animal.
Buy local. You can tell how well the chicken eats by the strength of the shell, the 2 distinct whites and the nice orange color of the yolk. Even the high DHA organic eggs at the store have pale yellow yolks, runny whites, and the shell crumbles into hundreds of pieces with the lightest tap.


Reesacat
Savvy User Savvy User Joined On 1/2007
Reesacat  
 
Posted On Jun 24, 2007
Phooey, thank you. 


Lynn46
Savvy User Savvy User Joined On 12/2006
Lynn46  
 
Posted On Jun 30, 2007
Bryan (Bryan-oz4caster),
I've just joined the discussingnt Yahoo group, and see that you frequently post messages there.

We both know that the Weston A Price Foundation (WAPF) strongly supports traditional foods including naturally raised eggs, poultry, and beef, and of course clean raw milk from grassfed cows. WAPF's position is that saturated fat from such food sources is very healthy with much research to back up this position. I have recently adopted a diet with such healthy foods to regain my health, and I have started to see good results. I have left the vegetable oils far, far behind.

To any VitalVotes readers who still question this concept:
There is absolutely nothing wrong with having saturated fat and cholesterol from healthy food sources (including coconut oil). In fact, these are absolutely essential for good health. Most vegetable oils (except extra virgin olive oil and virgin coconut oil) are the cause of chronic ill health, especially when combined with large amount of refined grains.

 
 
 
Posted On Jul 14, 2007
Eating cholesterol, in eggs, does NOT incease your cholesterol level.

 
eric3377
Novice User Novice User, Joined On 7/2007
eric3377  
 
 
 
Posted On Jul 17, 2007
Dr. Mercola,
Feeding fish to chickens is not part of a natural ecology. It irritates me that we learn one thing about nutrition and then we think it's okay to contrive a change in the food chain.

Please think about the logic behind feeding fish or fish oils to chickens.
Gina

 
GinaAnn
Novice User Novice User, Joined On 12/2006
GinaAnn  
Replied

BigEdd
Novice User Novice User Joined On 6/2007
BigEdd  
 
Posted On Jul 18, 2007
PPARGammaGirl,

What happened to you?   What did you think of my "Thorn Theory"?

I would like your comments on the olive oil and AIDS post.

 
 
 
 
© Copyright 2009 Dr. Joseph Mercola. All Rights Reserved. If you want to use this article on your site please click here. This content may be copied in full, with copyright, contact, creation and information intact, without specific permission, when used only in a not-for-profit format. If any other use is desired, permission in writing from Dr. Mercola is required.
* These statements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. This product is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any disease. If you are pregnant, nursing, taking medication, or have a medical condition, consult your physician before using this product.