SEARCH:
Sign in | Join | Help
search Mercola.com
 
FREE Subscription 
The World’s Most Popular Natural Health Newsletter
If You Aren't Using This Type of Exercise You Are Missing Out Big Time

New findings suggest that it pays to alternate short bursts of high-intensity exercise with gentle recovery during workout regimens at least once a week.

Although this alternating technique, called interval training, has existed for decades, a new study has confirmed that it can dramatically improve cardiovascular fitness and the body's fat-burning capabilities.

Researchers asked eight college-age men and women to sprint for 30 seconds, and then either stop or pedal gently for four minutes. After only two weeks of this interval training, 75 percent of them doubled their endurance.

A control group, which did not do any interval training, showed no improvement in endurance. The marked improvement in the interval training group was even more startling because the volunteers were already fairly fit.

Another study also showed that interval training enhances the body's ability to burn fat. Eight women in their early 20s were told to cycle for 10 sets of four minutes of hard riding, followed by two minutes of rest. After two weeks, the amount of fat burned in an hour of continuous moderate cycling increased by 36 percent, and their cardiovascular fitness improved by 13 percent.

New York Times May 3, 2007 (Registration Required)

The Ledger May 3, 2007

Journal of Applied Physiology, Vol. 102, No. 4, April 2007: 1439-1447


Dr. Mercola's Comment:

For most of my life I have focused on endurance aerobic training. When I was competing in college and for the next 15 years, I used to do interval training, but since I haven't competed for over 15 years, I stopped those workouts.

However, I have become ever more impressed with the convincing evidence of the usefulness of this technique. There is abundant new scientific evidence, like this study, that clearly demonstrates there are enormous benefits to interval-type training.

Personally, I now only run once a week and so do sprint training combined with pull-ups, dips, and singles tennis whenever I can find someone to play with. I just love tennis because it is, without question, the most fun I have when I exercise, and it gives a great opportunity to move in so many different directions.

This was motivated by Al Sears, MD who reawakened me to the value of interval training with his take on it which is called the P.A.C.E. program.

I also recently started Russian kettlebell training, which is also a very short high-intensity, interval-type activity. DragonDoor is the organization that introduced Russian kettlebells and is where you can find out more about them.

I now firmly believe that although endurance cardio training is important, it really needs to be part of a more comprehensive program that includes short bursts of activity at very high intensity that is individualized for your specific fitness level.

The new evidence suggests that this may actually provide MORE protection against heart attacks than long durational aerobic type exercises.

Another major benefit of this approach is that it radically decreases the amount of time you spend exercising, while giving you even more benefits.

It would be wise to have clearance by your physician if you are not in good shape before embarking on a program like this. However, you could start simply by walking and progress at your own pace.

But this is a technique that should help nearly anyone who uses it.

The take-home message?

Don't rely solely on cardio. You will need to incorporate interval-type training along with strength training to develop a far more rounded and comprehensive exercise program.

You will be very pleased with the results and perhaps even more pleased with the free time you have if you have been a slave to hour-long cardio workouts.

Related Articles:





 
 Do you find this article interesting?
Comment on This Article Community Comments (48)
 
 
Posted On May 03, 2007
Hi intesity cardio burns more fat than regular cardio because you will be burning calories hours after the workout is finished, also the short duration of the excercise will spare muscle mass, and sometimes even increase it.  

 

 
JL
Savvy User Savvy User, Joined On 6/2006
JL  
Replied

JL
Savvy User Savvy User Joined On 6/2006
JL  
 
Posted On May 03, 2007
A calorie is a unit of energy, and it will be burned during excercise whether it comes from fat, protein or sugar. 

Burning calories is just that, a burning of energy.  Whether it is good or bad for you depends on what type of fuel you are using.





phooey
Savvy User Savvy User Joined On 2/2007
phooey  
 
Posted On May 03, 2007
Check out the study in Metabolism 1994; 43 814-818. This study involved 1 group of participants doing an aerobic routine for 20 weeks versus an anaerobic group training for 15 weeks. The aerobic group also trained longer at each session. The end was interesting. The aerobic group burned 48% more calories, but the anaerobic group had a ninefold greater loss in subcutaneous fat. They trained less over a shorter period of time, burned fewer calories and lost far more body fat. Look at the difference in elite sprinters and marathon runners. Sprinters are leaner and more muscular. They train less, but more intense. The diet component is not studied enough in these studies, at least not long term. I believe that if you feed the body fat it will use fat. Feed it mostly sugar it will use sugar. It will try to run on what you give it. This is why most R.D.'s are wrong when they say that "Carbohydrates are the preferred fuel source for the body."
There are several other studies like the one mentioned if you go onto pubmed.gov and look.


Witch Doctor
Apprentice User Apprentice User Joined On 9/2006
Witch Doctor  
 
Posted On May 04, 2007
Fat is slow burning fuel, and is analogous to high octrane fuel.  High octane fuel burns slower than low octane fuel, allowing for smoother expansion in the cylinder during the power stroke.  Low octane fuel burns rapidly and under high load conditions tends to detonate ("ping") rather than burn, which is damaging to the engine.  Carbs also burn fast, and the body then "pings" with spikes of insulin which (like detonation) is damaging to the body.  Via insulin, the body converts the "low octane" fast burning carbs to "high octane" slow burning fats.

By the way, those who fear ingesting saturated fat should be aware that when they burn their own body fat, they are burning - guess what - saturated animal fat.

There was once an older guy who won the "over 50" marathon, and he did so well they tested him for drugs.  All they found is that he drank a cup of olive oil prior to the marathon.  Well, I will probably prefer 8 oz. of kidney fat, but hey...


Witch Doctor
Apprentice User Apprentice User Joined On 9/2006
Witch Doctor  
 
Posted On May 04, 2007
I believe Alpha Lipoic Acid (600 mg/day) and Benfotiamine (at least 100 mg/day, probably more - I can't recall) have been found to help with diabetic neuropathy.  (I wish I had the references at hand, but most of my references are sitting on a troubled hard drive that I am trying to recover the data from). 


cheftodd
Savvy User Savvy User Joined On 4/2007
cheftodd  
 
Posted On May 07, 2007
I do know that during the circuit training we did in our mixed martial arts was high intense cardio.every 5 min. we would switch from running to kicking/punching,to jiu-jitsu. I  was 315 pounds and less than a year I was 220.


Craig Wilcox
Savvy User Savvy User Joined On 9/2006
Craig Wilcox  
 
Posted On May 07, 2007
Yes, that's true.  However, the benefit of doing exercise in the "fat-burning zone", if done correctly, is that people actually stick to it. 

For those who have an aversion to exercise, teaching them to enjoy being in the fat-burning zone is easy.  Telling them to go as fast as they can to burn more fat is a sure fire way to induce long-term failure.  The aversion will grow, they'll give it up, and they'll likely end up gaining more weight back than they lost.

I know the official position of board certified physical trainers is to burn as many calories as possible.  Most of the people who are certified to "dispel the myth of fat-burning" have never had a weight problem themselves.


seg
Savvy User Savvy User Joined On 11/2006
seg  
 
Posted On May 15, 2007
Al Sears got the best exercise programe in the world believe me his PACE programe is without a shadow of a doubt the best. i have subscribed to his site for many years now since 2004 i believe  after the heart attack and always amazed at what he has to say. I'm convinced Long duration exercises have caused my "mild" heart attack in 2004 at 42 yrs old and have since then rehabed with his recommendations and best of all it only takes mere mins a day, 6 mins to no more than 20 mins tops 3 to 4 times a week.Before i did everything, weights (i love weights), cardio etc.. 3 to 4 times a week, 1 hour each session and the day before i got my MI I did an extra 15 mins and look where it got me yeah a MI. thank goodness for Al sears and doc merc i'm not on any drugs cept take aspirin every once in a while with nattokinase, probiotic, vit b some time for inflammation and carlson cod liver oil. i feel so much better now than when i was on the statins and the other 4 drugs they give you when you walk out of the hospital . the first day i got so dizzy that i called my cardiologist and hes said to discontinue the high blood pressure drug ALTACE  i believe, it was then the dizziness continued and they had to take me of another one (can't remember the one now)  that was taking my heart rate down to to low 30 beats per minute and causing more dizziness. to make a long story short over time i stopped taking all the drugs and my blood work have always been fine, my cardiologist still wants me to continue on 20 mgs of lipitor for fear the stent they put in might block and i told him no sir. good diet, proper exercise not the long cardio, sleep amongst other things the good docs recommend and all will be o.k


seg
Savvy User Savvy User Joined On 11/2006
seg  
 
Posted On May 15, 2007
cardio just burns sugar "while" you're exercising and depending on how long you go you can also eat up your musclesand destroy the lining of your blood vessels so plaque can stick to it.
anerobic or interval training goes a long way furthur by  burning the sugars from your muscles while exercising but after the workout it continues to burn FAT not your muscles and after a while your body realises it don't need to HOG THE FAT as reserves for the next day session as it does with long duration exercises like cardio.....with the short  burst or interval training you don't eat up your muscles but long after you finish your body continue to burn fat.
the trick is to start of slow, and go up to about 20 mins max, past that you're asking for trouble you can eat up the lining of your blood vessels. Work up to 20 mins then DECREASE THE TIME BUT INCREASE THE INTENSITY/RESISTANCE never increase the time you want to do more in less time, THIS WOULD INCREASE YOUR CARDIO/PULMONARY RESERVE WHICH IS WHAT YOU NEED, make your heart bigger and stronger. Cardio does the exact opposite, it makes your heart smaller because smaller goes "longer" like long distance runners their hearts are smaller because it has to be more efficient to go longer. just look at the bodies of a long distance runner and a sprinter like Green, see the difference in their bodies.
Do more in less time and vary your work out because your body gets accustomed to the same thing day in day out. EG if  you run 2 KM in 20 minutes the next week try to run the same 2KM in 19 mins and progress as you go, next week do it in 18 etc.BUT DO IT GRADUALLY..
REMEMBER LESS IS MORE
For more info see alsearsmd.com  for his PACE programe, it's revolutionary believe me...


HealingMindN
Apprentice User Apprentice User Joined On 5/2007
HealingMindN  
 
Posted On May 15, 2007
In response to cheftodd, when we analyse martial arts we recognise that it is the oldest form of interval training.  From a hard styles perspective, we intermix intense kata and sparring with (ki or chi) breathing exercises as a form of cool down.  I understand this "peak and valley" approach gives the body time to adjust to higher levels of training each time.


ratboy83
Novice User Novice User Joined On 8/2007
ratboy83  
 
Posted On Nov 04, 2008
in response to the first post by phooey. your ascertion that the body will use what you give it is a little simplistic. studies have shown that, in the context of sports nutrition, high fat-low carbohydrate diets do result in a physiological adaptions in an attempt to improve utilisation of the substrate (fat) available through changes in mitochodrial efficiency. However, these studies have two major flaws: when examining exercise performance they lacked a high carbohydrate group; secondly, the exercise involved was performed at an intensity below 65% VO2 max. although the level of performance was good on the high fat diet, the lack of a comparison to a high CHO group means it is impossible to conclude that the high fat diet would have resulted in superior exercsie performance to a high CHO diet. more significantly, although the high fat diet was able to sustain ATP resynthesis at the intensity of 65% VO2 max, fat cannot efficiently sustain exercise at intesities above 65% VO2 max. This is significant considering sport and elite level physical activity is typically performed at intensities greatly exceeding this level.
The body utilises all types of fuel simultaneously when exercising, but the releative contribution of differenmt types of fuel changes accroding to:-

a) the intensity of exercise (higher the intensity, the greater the % from CHO and less from fat)
b) the level of glycogen (depelted glycogen leads to a drop in intensity and so a shift to fat, and in the later stages an increase in protein utilisation

ideally, the body uses fat where possible (everyday low intensity activities use fat, although only CHO can be used by the nervous system), due to its abundency in the body compared to samll CHO stores and this is why adaptions from endurance training allows greater fat useage. but the only substrate capable of sustaining high intensity exercise is CHO. glycolysis cannot use fat, only CHO.  alex.

 
 
 
Posted On May 03, 2007
JL,
That is the concensus, but there is not research on that. Most of what you said has been passed down over and over again. Most do not know the science behind it, nor there is none. If that were true, most would be doing it and most of society wouldn't be obese.

Here are my conclusions from recent research that I have found:

When you work out, do circuits or do short intense 30 minute workouts, your cortisol, test and other growth hormones rise. It has been shown that around 30 minutes workout, etc, your test and GH start to come down, but cortisol stays up. So that is why doing long cardio sessions just burns muscle and not fat. Cortisol is a fat storing hormone. As well, anytime cortisol goes up and your blood sugar drops from those long hours of cardio, your adrenals release adrenaline as well to help to balance your blood sugar issues. So not only do you cause adrenal stress, and store fat with long duration of cardio, but you as well create blood sugar handling issues.

With people trying to drop weight, I always recommend 2:1 ratio intervals, 30 minute circuit workouts and nothing longer. This will help to reduce fat storage, keep cortisol levels down, balance out their building hormones and balance blood sugar levels.

Unfortunately most think it is all about calories. But in all reality, it has very little to do with it. There is a lot of research, as well as documumentation by Poliquin, CHEK and other leaders in the field proving that by eating for their MT, taking in lots of calories, and just working out for short peroids without any cardio!

 
Josh Rubin
Moderator User Moderator User, Joined On 6/2006
Josh Rubin  
Replied

moises
Apprentice User Apprentice User Joined On 6/2006
moises  
 
Posted On May 03, 2007
Josh Rubin wrote:
With people trying to drop weight, I always recommend 2:1 ratio intervals . . .

I am not trying to lose weight, but found your advice intriguing. I know that Tabata's protocol was 6 or 7 sets of 20 seconds exertion: 10 seconds recovery, preceded and followed by a 5-minute warm-up and cool-down. Is this your recommendation as well. Most of what I've read, other than Tabata, suggests 1:1 or lower.



Witch Doctor
Apprentice User Apprentice User Joined On 9/2006
Witch Doctor  
 
Posted On May 03, 2007
Josh - can you provide a concrete example of "2:1 ratio intervals, 30 minute circuit workouts"?  Then I'll just do that and not bother researching.  I have faith in you, bro!  Thanks.


JL
Savvy User Savvy User Joined On 6/2006
JL  
 
Posted On May 03, 2007
Here are some studies that support high-intensity over medium-intensity cardio.

Studies

Josh, I agree with most of what you are saying about the unpredictability of a workout translated in fat loss, many factors come into play here, but you make Hi-Intensity cardio sound like it is easier to do when in fact the opposite is true.   It takes a great deal of will power and commitment to stick to a program like this.  The mind-body starts to fear this type of training and you will soon look at those long 45minute cardio sessions as fun and comfortable, the problem is they don't produce the same results. 

Someone who I admire very much used to say "Beneath the suffering lies the beauty of opportunity." 




Josh Rubin
Moderator User Moderator User Joined On 6/2006
Josh Rubin  
 
Posted On May 03, 2007
JL,
That is why high intensity (as you put it) training for each individual would be different. Each person is at their own level and you just don't go head first into 85% Max HR,etc. YOu need to work with a prioritized program at hand that gets you up to your "high intensity" cardio workout potential.

There are so many schools of thought and when it comes down to it, do what is right for you all!


Pat Ormsby
Savvy User Savvy User Joined On 6/2006
Pat Ormsby  
 
Posted On May 05, 2007
I can attest to what you are saying, Josh, from my own recent experience. I love endurance-type activities, but note that whenever I engage in them I gain weight, and it isn't muscle. As an experiment, last autumn I tried jogging 90 min./day, six days a week, with 1500 kcal/day and in the course of two months, gained about a pound. Then (thanks to tips from this site), I switched to a variety of anaerobic exercizes with an occasional day of mountain climbing. I've lost more than two pounds and look much better.

 
 
 
Posted On May 03, 2007
Interval Training was a basic requirement in the track and filed program I was in, back in the late 60's & early 70's, as well as thelong distance running program.  

IT (Interval Training) is an absolute cornerstone toward good health and bettered performances.

We also as runners were REQUIRED to go on LSD (Long Slow Distance) in an odd/even day training week.

The results across the team?  VERY GOOD to WORLD BEATERS.

 
Russ Bianchi
Savvy User Savvy User, Joined On 9/2006
Russ Bianchi  
 
 
 
Posted On May 07, 2007
Along the lines of proatc's "what's everybody's favorite cereal", what is everybody's favorite anaerobic?  Humorous replies more than welcome, because that may be as beneficial than exercise.  Serious replies too, though.  Thanks!

 
Witch Doctor
Apprentice User Apprentice User, Joined On 9/2006
Witch Doctor  
Replied

Witch Doctor
Apprentice User Apprentice User Joined On 9/2006
Witch Doctor  
 
Posted On May 08, 2007
You're just bragging!  Good start.  Perhaps I will alternate between breathing while glass-lifting, and not breathing.  Wait - while at the lips, breathing may cease.  Yes, definitely anaerobic, combined with aerobic.  I will get some right now.  When I fall off my chair, have I reached anaerobic exhaustion?

 
 
 
Posted On May 08, 2007
Has anyone heard of "roving"?  I read about it when I was a teenager.  You walk until the "spirit moves you" to run.  Run until it's unpleasant, then walk.  When your energy returns, you run again.  That's all.  Over time, you run more, and walk more or less as you prefer.  Running will typically be at a faster gait than jogging, less jarring to the joints.  No distance requirement, no pressure.  This probably has a new name, now.

 
Witch Doctor
Apprentice User Apprentice User, Joined On 9/2006
Witch Doctor  
Replied

HansMassage_203
Apprentice User Apprentice User Joined On 6/2006
HansMassage_203  
 
Posted On May 15, 2007
I use the phrase I picked up from one of Check's programs.
Do your hear FUN in functional exercise. 
I am proscribed by turf battle legislation from prescribing exercise but I am allowed to teach movement that will balance and restore muscle function.   When I do so I get the question "how many times do I repeat and how often."  which I can not tell them but i can repeat Check's rule. Do it only as long as it is fun then do something else for a while and then se if it is fun again.
Hans Albert Quistorff, LMP
Antalgic  Posture Pain Specialist

 
 
 
 
© Copyright 2009 Dr. Joseph Mercola. All Rights Reserved. If you want to use this article on your site please click here. This content may be copied in full, with copyright, contact, creation and information intact, without specific permission, when used only in a not-for-profit format. If any other use is desired, permission in writing from Dr. Mercola is required.
* These statements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. This product is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any disease. If you are pregnant, nursing, taking medication, or have a medical condition, consult your physician before using this product.