SEARCH:
Sign in | Join | Help
search Mercola.com
 
FREE Subscription 
The World’s Most Popular Natural Health Newsletter
Can the Pet Food Calamity Also Harm You?

According to the FDA, thousands of hogs in a number of states, as well as poultry at a Missouri farm, ate pet food that had been laced with the industrial chemical melamine.

This means that the contaminant, which has been responsible for the deaths of pets across the United States, has potentially entered the human food supply.

Urine from hogs in California, North Carolina, and South Carolina tested positive for melamine, and it is possible that hogs in New York, Utah, and Ohio may have done so as well.

The FDA believes that melamine was added to Chinese products to artificially inflate their nitrogen content, and therefore their price. FDA inspections have steadily dropped over the past few years, while at the same time the use of imported food has increased greatly.

The FDA plans to begin tests of imported Chinese corn gluten and corn meal, soy protein, rice bran and rice protein concentrate, and wheat gluten.

These products are used as ingredients in many foods ranging from breakfast cereal to baby formula. The now recalled pet food contained contaminated wheat gluten that had been designated suitable for human consumption, although there is as yet no evidence that it directly entered the human food supply.

Boston.com April 25, 2007

USA Today April 20, 2007


Dr. Mercola"s Comment:

In addition to melamine, a chemical used to make fertilizer and plastics, the FDA is testing Chinese imports for cyanuric acid, another high-nitrogen chemical also used as a pool and hot tub cleaner.

There"s a simple explanation for this poisoning of pets, and possibly humans, in this country, apart from the chemicals themselves -- the lack of proper oversight. Frankly, if contaminated rice, soy, and corn products have not ended up in the processed foods sold in your corner grocery store, it"s because of a lucky coincidence, not the result of infrequent government inspections.

Of course, it"s easy for unscrupulous manufacturers to add extra chemicals to processed foods, as well. When the ingredients are refined, dehydrated, synthetic, or stripped down to powder, who"s going to notice a few chemicals more or less ... at least, until they start causing problems.

It"s easy to slip in unhealthy chemicals because these "foods" already are unhealthy chemicals. It"s much more difficult to adulterate natural, organic, whole foods, however; why and how would anyone add melamine to a carrot, for instance?

This is particularly tragic for all the pets that lost their lives because of this mistake. But nearly all conventional pets are just as seriously misfed as the general public.

Commercial pet food is a disaster waiting to happen, as this story clearly demonstrates. Pets, just like you, were designed to consume unprocessed and, for the most part, uncooked, raw foods. When one deviates from those choices, disease -- and not health -- results.

I am very close to partnering with a vet who is my equivalent in the pet world, and I am excited to have him share his message that so needs to be heard as millions of pets are suffering needlessly.

There"s no better time than the present to step away from processed foods and begin to optimize your health and eating based on your body"s unique nutritional type. You can protect yourself even further, if you want, by purchasing local food directly from the farms of producers you know and trust, through a CSA or other local food organization.

As for your pets, you can safeguard their health by feeding them a naturally balanced diet of raw meat and vegetables that"s better than any processed pet food. Until I shore up the final details with my new vet expert, if you want further information you can review the excellent book, See Spot Live Longer, which emphasizes nutritional philosophies similar to my own.

Related Articles:





 
 Do you find this article interesting?
Comment on This Article Community Comments (55)
 
 
Posted On Apr 26, 2007
Several years ago, I raised a simple question in a national food scientific colloquium, on the subject of pet food processing. 

There were many veterinarians and animal nutritionists and experts in this field in the audience, mostly working for larger processed pet food companies.

The question was: "Could anyone comment on reports (I had read) that European dogs, particularly in Spain and Italy, eating human table scraps (veggies, pasta, unprocessed meat/poultry/fish/lamb, polenta, rice, etc.), live an average of 6 to 7 years longer than American counterparts, versus dogs eating processed canned, aseptic, or dry dog food here (USA)?"

I thought I was going to be lynched on the spot, by the incredulous verbal reactions, and knee-jerk denunciations of my question that ensued (and no one answering the the question asked)! 

It was a free-for-all for the next 20 minutes, until the moderator, on the panel I was sitting on, moved on to another subject.

Obviously, I was NOT invited back the next year.

Though I have personally formulated several dog food biscuits (all natural, GRAS, and from low processed ingredient sources, as well as nutrient ) I hit a major nerve of some participants in the above described event.

This story magnifies my belief that indeed there is little oversight in food safety in the pet, or human, food chain, until something bad emerges from bad results, that cannot be brushed under the carpet, by either producers, ingredient suppliers, or so-called out numbered regulators (because there is a body count).

And oh, if you are wondering, our 13 year old tea cup Pomeranian gets human food, correctly portioned, from our table, and is in EXCELLENT health for her age.

Prevention remains less costly than reactive treatment or cures. 

 
Russ Bianchi
Savvy User Savvy User, Joined On 9/2006
Russ Bianchi  
Replied

foxtroter_203
Savvy User Savvy User Joined On 9/2006
foxtroter_203  
 
Posted On Apr 26, 2007
Most dog foods have a high carbohydrate level, often because of the corn in them. Since when do carnivorous dogs eat such a high level of carbohydrate? No wonder so many dogs are now being put on “diet” dog food. My vet a while back was encouraging low fat diets for overweight dogs. Hmm, I have never seen low fat, high carb rabbits and squirrels etc. What a laugh.


Witch Doctor
Apprentice User Apprentice User Joined On 9/2006
Witch Doctor  
 
Posted On Apr 26, 2007
Oh foxtroter, FOXTROTER... you missed your chance at a double trump! You are right, BUT the "diet" dogfoods are even higher carb!  They are all complete numbskulls.  Like I say, 90% of everything is bullsh*t. 


Bridestein
Savvy User Savvy User Joined On 12/2006
Bridestein  
 
Posted On Apr 27, 2007
Foxtroter - I think dogs might really be omnivorous., or maybe mine was just a "mixed type". We never got to harvest our strawberries, because she always ate them while they were still green. She was always eating blackberries and grass. Whenever we couldn't find her when we got home, we knew to look in the compost bin because she would tunnel underneath it and then eat so much she couldn't get back out. She did like corn too, in fact the only veggies she refused to eat was potatoes, onions and olives.
We fed her canned and dry food, so perhaps she was just supplementing to meet her needs. Spanky was a pitbull, but my in-laws' airedale also eats blackberries.


Katharine
Apprentice User Apprentice User Joined On 6/2006
Katharine  
 
Posted On Apr 27, 2007
I think you have a valid point about the European table scrap eating dog's health. Obviously there is a lot more money to be made selling packaged "dog food" than a little extra meat and rice at the supermarket so no motivation for vets/scientists or anyone who wants $ to look into that option. Yet, pre-packaged dog food is probably a bit more nutritious than the table scraps a dog would get in the average Amercian household. Does that mean that Americans should start eating dog food?


Witch Doctor
Apprentice User Apprentice User Joined On 9/2006
Witch Doctor  
 
Posted On Apr 27, 2007
Bridestein - you may be right, Josh Rubin's die-hard holistic friends may be right, or Foxtroter might be right.  I did see a reference in "The Once and Future King" to putting medieval dogs "out to pasture" (out to run, really) to get some healthy grass, but it was written in 1950s (?) and may have been flavored by modern thinking?  I feed 'em raw meat and bones, all types (cheap types), so maybe they get everything they need and don't need to rummage through veggies.  With their remarkable sense of smell, pehaps they can sniff out minerals they are lacking.

I do get lazy periods where they get dry food, so maybe I will notice this behavior. 


3D
Apprentice User Apprentice User Joined On 2/2007
3D  
 
Posted On Apr 27, 2007
Ooops.  Was just trying to give this comment thumbs up and hit thumbs down by mistake.

Great comment.  I worked briefly at a vet school where we did nutritional "research" for a major feed and pet food supplier who made huge endowments to the university.  This was late '70s.  Very scary, very scary stuff going on.  Even those opposed were scared to speak up.

I've been telling friends for years that the expensive pet food they were buying was basically the same as the cheaper brand, and manufactured by same people.  They never believed me.  Heck, I have been right about so much stuff over the past 30 yrs that most of them don't speak to me anymore because they would either have to apologize or admit I was right.  No big loss.

Love Mercola's site.  Been spreading his articles around for the last 3 months or so. 


sandrews
Novice User Novice User Joined On 4/2007
sandrews  
 
Posted On Apr 28, 2007
the food scares are happening because of the carelessness in processing plants. the worse thing is that it keeps happening because the usda and the fda let it happen, they won't take care of it they are in for profit and they don't care. that's very unfortunate but true. look at what they feed animals on those awful factory farms. they feed those animals substances that go far from what God intended for them to eat. not to mention the fact that they are abused and maimed on a regular basis throughout their entire lives. that is why the animals are so sick and that is why people and the animals seen as pets become ill. all because of diseased, contaminated food from these facility's. take Dr. Mercola's advice and buy the food for you and your four-legged friends from local farmers. you will be healthier and you will also help to keep the local farmers in business,


Dr. Lori
Novice User Novice User Joined On 12/2006
Dr. Lori  
 
Posted On Apr 30, 2007
I have been feeding my dog what I eat since he was a puppy.  I am so glad I made that decision since this whole pet food scare has become such an issue.  My dog is doing great for his age, which I believe is due to this fact.  (For the record, he does have a bowl of dry dog food sitting out so he can eat if he's hungry during the day when no one's home, though he rarely eats it...that should tell you something about manufactured dog food right there...he has unlimited access, and barely touches it...most dogs would have it gobbled up.)


Eel
Novice User Novice User Joined On 5/2007
Eel  
 
Posted On May 11, 2007
My last dog, and my neighbor's dog died within a week of eachother.  I suspected the drenching of our area with Monsanto products to kill weeds.

My new dogs, and my 3 large parrots, my husband and myself drink blender liquified organic greens, plus water,  an apple or banana, or both every morning.  The birds and dogs love it.  Live enzymes.  Surprisingly energizing.  Our people bodies start craving less dense food, and we have become more calm and present.  No trumpets, no huge cures, just a step in the right direction, I really think.

 
 
 
Posted On Apr 26, 2007
This post was deleted because it violated our Terms Of Use :
Comment does not pertain to the topic of the article or does not provide value or insight to the discussion. Submit stories or comments linking to affiliate programs, multi-level marketing schemes, or off-topic content or any other system that will result in your personal financial or commercial gain.

 
Katy B
Savvy User Savvy User, Joined On 3/2007
Katy B  
Replied

Pat Ormsby
Savvy User Savvy User Joined On 6/2006
Pat Ormsby  
 
Posted On Apr 30, 2007
China is terribly lax. Other countries may be better, but it would still be worthwhile to buy locally for many reasons. Or better yet, grow your own!

 
 
 
Posted On Apr 26, 2007
I was wondering if anyone else in the Vital Votes community remembers when the pet-food recall was first discussed on the news, they mentioned a chemical that was used for Rat poison in other countries.  They stated that the only use for this (drug) in our country was for cancer treatment. It was reported this way for 2-3 days and then the report mentioned melamine.  Were there two different chemicals? I believe that there is far more put in our food, or sprayed on our food then we can possibly imagine. 

 
PepperR23
Savvy User Savvy User, Joined On 6/2006
PepperR23  
Replied

Russ Bianchi
Savvy User Savvy User Joined On 9/2006
Russ Bianchi  
 
Posted On Apr 27, 2007
The 3/23/07 USA Today, front page article, entitled: "Pet food maker to pay for vet bills" discusses the rat poison issue. 

Or you may merely search engine: 'rat poison in dog food' & get several cross references.

Aminopectin (rat poison) was FOUND/announced by both the US EPA (FEDERAL) & New York State health/inspection authorities, in the Menu Foods producrs; that then triggered further revelations on the tainted fake/dangerous protein supplementation from China.

The bottom line is in the 15+ billion dollar per year pet food industry in the USA, there is has been little, or no standard, save maximizing PROFITS, at the long term health of animals, for MANY DECADES.

The BODY COUNT OF DEATHS outed them this time.

HOWEVER, Veterinarians (many with vested interests in treating sick & dying animals from poor processed food intake) have also KNOWN that canned, aseptic & dry dog or cat food, or other 'chows' or 'chew toys', though typically microbiological and bacteriologically sound, will claim before investigative commissions, or PR firm orchestrated sound bites on radio, and TV talk shows, to be 'sound science and good nutrition'.

Yeah right, and we have some swamp land to sell you, complete with alligators living long lives, not on processed pet food!

In point of fact, the EVIDENCE remains that there are many fillers, byproducts, emulsifiers, binders, sugars, modified starches, fake colors, fake flavors, preservatives, stabilizers, water binders, gelatins, pectins, tumor causing or triggering ingredients, along with these poisons or Chinese harmful ingredients, STILL OUT THERE, & not under any scrutiny.

The Pet Food processors are WORRIED that this scandal will NOT go away this time (via litigation & insurance carriers paying off damages) & it will cost them, & consumers MORE, to use quality ingredients.


Mercola Fan
Apprentice User Apprentice User Joined On 11/2006
Mercola Fan  
 
Posted On May 10, 2007
YES THANKS FOR BRINGING THAT UP. That was going to be my comment...isn't it interesting how the story changed??
The rat poison..aka...cancer treatment drug, aminoptherin, was conclusively found in the tainted food. Then, BAM, the story changes...I smell a poisoned rat!
It is also interesting how everyone (the masses) seemed to be unaffected by the news that a drug used for cancer treatment in this country was used as rat poison in another. The reason it is not used for rat poison in this country is because it is outlawed here for that purpose. Then WHY is it being fed to cancer patients?
 I think that may be the most concerning thing in this whole story.

It is also interesting that when the story was reported it was unusual to hear aminoptherin (the drug they conclusively found when they tested) referred to as a cancer drug and a rat poison in the same report. It is however BOTH things. >>Cancer treatment in this country, rat poison other places in the world. Shouldn't that make us question sharply the way this country treats cancer?? Shouldn't it make us question sharply if people are really dying from cancer...or are they dying/poisoned from the "treatment">>?

Here is the link to a story on this that was in the Washington Post:
in this report they call aminoptherin a rat poison, in the 2nd one they call it a cancer drug.
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2007/03/23/AR2007032300814.html

http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/17754681/

Mercola RULZ!!

 
 
 
Posted On Apr 26, 2007
I do feed my animals high quality organic wet and dry food. But I do know some die hard people that live the holistic lifestyle that buy ground beef, pork and chicken. They lightly cook it with certain veggies and add cod liver oil and other oils on afterwards. This is given to their dogs for every meal.

 
Josh Rubin
Moderator User Moderator User, Joined On 6/2006
Josh Rubin  
Replied

Witch Doctor
Apprentice User Apprentice User Joined On 9/2006
Witch Doctor  
 
Posted On Apr 26, 2007
Josh - why do they cook it?  The cod liver oil makes sense because the meat may not be grassfed or otherwise have its natural n-3 content.  But vegetables? 

When I take my three dogs out they chase rabbits, have gotten good at it, and actually cornered a jackrabbit, got ahold of it and in fighting over it they tore it apart.  I let them have it.  Regarding the multifarious vegetation they encounter - once in a while they'll sniff or nudge up against some plant (I'm not counting territorrial marker sniffing), but really that's rare and they don't have much interest in veggetation, anywhere they encounter it.  Are your holistic friends anthropomrphising a bit?  Grass is about all they want, and only when they want it - not daily rations.  And  as far as I know, dogs would never take the trouble to cook their food.  They're as lazy as I am.

Thanks.  Duane


Bridestein
Savvy User Savvy User Joined On 12/2006
Bridestein  
 
Posted On Apr 27, 2007
Duane, it's been my experience that sometimes people who anthropomorphize have had abusive childhoods. Some go to the opposite extreme and don't credit any living thing with having feelings.
Sometimes the line between pet and "family member" is just getting a little blurred, but frequently people have been so traumatized by other humans that they project their emotions onto animals who love you and don't belittle you, beat you or otherwise abuse you and are grateful for whatever you're willing to give them.
The managing editor of the newspaper I used to work for was the meanest a-hole anyone had ever met, but he had two cats who were his "babies" and he just loved them to death. And so I knew that deep down he was a very insecure, scarred man who must have been treated very badly, probably by his parents. This knowledge helped me tremendously when he used to scream at me. I sure didn't appreciate it, but I never took it personally.
When your own parents don't love you it is a HUGE handicap for a child to overcome in life. Lots never do; some find other ways of dealing with it like idealizing animals. Try not to judge too harshly.
I'm sorry, I'm really not trying to preach at you, this is just my opinion.   ;-)


Bridestein
Savvy User Savvy User Joined On 12/2006
Bridestein  
 
Posted On Apr 27, 2007
Duane - my dog used to eat jackrabbits too, but also grass, fruits and vegetables. We called her our cow-dog. Maybe I wasn't feeding her as well as you feed your dogs.


Witch Doctor
Apprentice User Apprentice User Joined On 9/2006
Witch Doctor  
 
Posted On Apr 27, 2007
Bridestein - I've been waiting for someone to put me in my place, because I cringe when I happen to reread some of my stuff.  I'll "meditate" on your experience, and this will hopefully prove to be a revelation to explain more of the world to me.  I never take what I write too seriously, but others may.  Plus I don't know what my personal BS quotient is because I am too wrapped up inside myself to tell.

As far as pets, go, it's useful to remember that they are lifelong immature, because they don't have to provide for themselves, their den, make their own shelter, protect themselves and their den, prepare for winter, etc... like other animals in nature.  So people look at their pet as a model of nature, and sure they are more instinctive, but emotionally and rationally they are not a reflection of that cold, hard, brutal, unforgiving, scary and therefore wondrous place that is nature.  They are kids til they die.


Bridestein
Savvy User Savvy User Joined On 12/2006
Bridestein  
 
Posted On Apr 27, 2007
I'm sorry Duane if you feel I was trying to put you in your place. I would never do that. Sometimes I say things with a lack of finesse. I was trying to put you in my place. :-)


Witch Doctor
Apprentice User Apprentice User Joined On 9/2006
Witch Doctor  
 
Posted On Apr 27, 2007
Bridestein - I just read you, and at first I thought a reprimand was in order because "I'm sorry" always rankles me (I wonder if I said that in any of my posts?) - maybe I heard it too many times from my ex -wife (who is a wonderful mother of my children by the way).  Anyways, I opened and read the rest and you pulled it off so well... So now I'm sorry.  I was thinking you had originally written the most reasonable admonition, and then I got to "Try not to judge too harshly." and immediately all of my recent sins came back to me, and I thought it was what I was waiting for and it finally happened.  So I said it.  That's all.


SandyDog
Novice User Novice User Joined On 5/2007
SandyDog  
 
Posted On May 10, 2007
Hi Josh:  i am one of those die hard people that feed their dogs and cats the ultimate diet.  The best book to read is Give Your Dog  A Bone by Dr. Ian Billingshurst. He is an Austrailian Vet and goes into detail. There is a lot of info on the net also if you type in BARF (biologically Approved Raw Food). You will not find Bar-B-Q grills in the wild or a wild dog, fox, coyoke, etc muching down on corn or wheat. They are omnivores. Cats are carnivores. I have a commercial grinder for my cats (asian leopards) also known as Bengals. I have a lab that is allergic to grains and thats how it got started. You must give raw and raw bone for it to be balanced. All vegtable matter has to be squashed by my juicer or food processor to immitate a pre-digested state as well for their short digestive track to absorb. Cooked food is 'dead' food. All food is utilized, no doggy odors, fleas, no gum and teeth problems, no excess body fat, no allergies anymore, small poopies and I could go on. The immune system is very strong because they are eating how God intended them to eat. Unfortunatley I can not afford Organic for them. I do add organic supplements though like C.O.D., coconut oil, fish oil, E, some buffered C, and Kelp.  The evening meals i give raw meaty bones like chicken backs or necks, and wings. I rotate with turkey and chicken. Check out this website. http://www.alt4animals.com/nutrition.htm

 
 
 
Posted On Apr 26, 2007
In reference to what Katybr55 mentioned, I have seen at least one television piece on China's rapidly emerging super-economy. One thing that was pointed out was the fact that China, for the most part, has little governmental regulatory controls over any of their industries similar to the oversight of the USFDA, USDA, USEPA, USFTC, and so on, not that the US agencies always do such a wonderful job in regulating and overseeing US industries. The contaminated wheat gluten and, later, included rice protein concentrate as well, are of course highly processed grain products that were added to dog and cat food.

I am now very suspect of any food product exported by China until they can prove that their foodstuff exports are not deliberately or accidentally contaminated. Not to be too much of a conspiracy nut or something, but I can imagine a terrorist group loose in China trying to create havoc in the US by deliberately contaminating food products that the terrorists know will be exported to the US. China's government and governmental operations are still, for the most part, closed to scrutiny by other nations.

But the more basic question now, is why add grain products to dog and cat food at all? These animals are carnivores who need to be on a very high-protein, animal-source-based diet. Well, the reason, of course, is grain product fillers save the mega-pet-food conglomerates a huge amount of money! Remember, when it comes to mega-corporations, the bottom line is god to the boards of directors and the corporations' biggest-share stockholders.

Fortunately for my 4 cats, I have been buying organic and grain-free smaller-producer canned and dry food for some time. So, I have not had to worry about how I'm going to pay for vet bills for kidney failure problems. Lately, I also have been cooking chicken and salmon meals for about 3 - 4 meals per week.

 
Lynn46
Savvy User Savvy User, Joined On 12/2006
Lynn46  
 
 
 
 
© Copyright 2009 Dr. Joseph Mercola. All Rights Reserved. If you want to use this article on your site please click here. This content may be copied in full, with copyright, contact, creation and information intact, without specific permission, when used only in a not-for-profit format. If any other use is desired, permission in writing from Dr. Mercola is required.
* These statements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. This product is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any disease. If you are pregnant, nursing, taking medication, or have a medical condition, consult your physician before using this product.